James Suckling beschreibt den Chateau Poesia 2016 am 25 April 2019 wie folgt:
Subtle aromas of mint. bay leaf and dark berries follow through to a full body with chewy and polished tannins and a tight. structured finish. Extremely long and firm. Give this at least another four or five years to soften and come together. Try after 2023.
Jeb Dunnuck bewertet den Chateau Poesia 2016 im Februar 2019 wie folgt:
A blend of 70% Merlot and 30% Cabernet Franc. the 2016 Château Poesia is more open and showy compared to the Barde Haut. offering fabulous limestone-like character in its kirsch and currant fruits and notes of dried herbs. white truffle. and dried flowers. Possessing medium to full body. ripe. present tannins. terrific concentration. and a great finish. it's another incredibly classy Saint Emilion from the Garcin-Lévêque family.
Der einzige Bordeaux in der RPWA’s team "coup de coeur" Liste für 2019
Lisa Perrotti Brown bewertet den Chateau Poesia 2016 Saint Emilion Grand Cru wie folgt:
The 2016 Poesia is a blend of 70% Merlot and 30% Cabernet Franc. Deep garnet-purple. the nose delivers vibrant Black Forest cake. redcurrants and Morello cherries notes with touches of cinnamon stick. rose hip tea. pencil shavings. tobacco and milk chocolate. The medium-bodied palate charges out of the gate with bright red berries layers and loads of herbal sparks. framed by rock-solid. ripe. grainy tannins and bold freshness. finishing very long. It should offer very good aging potential.
Das Statement des Wineadvocate zu der neu geschaffenen Ehrung der TOP TEN Weine des gesamten Jahres als "coup de coeur"
Lisa Perrotti-Brown 22 Nov 2019
News & Views As an introduction to the New York City Matter of Taste wine tasting event. the Robert Parker Wine Advocate’s team gathered to launch the very first selection of our wine reviewers’ favorites: their 10 discoveries of the year. True to Robert Parker’s vision to independently evaluate and highlight wines from all around the world. this innovative move will encourage wine lovers to explore new territories and learn about the passionate work of wine makers. At Gabriel Kruether’s two-MICHELIN-starred restaurant. our team of wine critics demonstrated their commitment for bringing to the public’s knowledge the talents of tomorrow. beyond their already extensive annual review of fine wines. We are pleased to reveal that RPWA’s team “coup de coeur” for 2019 are:
2017 Lismore Estate Reserve Chardonnay. Western Cape. South Africa
2017 Scar of the Sea Chardonnay Seven Leagues. Santa Maria Valley. California
2015 Charles Perez Côtes du Roussillon Les Aspres MVD MMXV. Roussillon. France
Chambers Rosewood Vineyards Rare Muscat (Multi-Vintage). Rutherglen. Australia
2016 Poesia. Saint Emilion. Bordeaux
2015 Domaines Lupier La Dama. Navarra. Spain
2011 Kir-Yianni Diaporos Block 5. Macedonia. Greece
2017 Planeta Sicilia Carricante Eruzione 1614. Etna. Sicily. Italy
2017 Martin Muthenthaler Riesling Viesslinger Stern. Wachau. Austria
2013 NV Ulysse Collin Extra Brut Blanc de Blancs Les Roises. Champagne. France