James Suckling über den Chateau Saint Pierre 2019 Saint Julien:
Very pretty and typical for the appellation with aromas of blackcurrants, violets and sandalwood that follow through to a full body with layers of polished tannins and a long, flavorful finish. Lasts a long time on the palate. Classic structure. Drink after 2027.
Antonio Galloni (Vinous) bewertet den Chateau Saint Pierre 2019 Saint Julien:
The 2019 Saint-Pierre is a Saint-Julien of real substance and presence. Inky black fruit, gravel, scorched earth, new oak, espresso, lavender and menthol build into the wine's huge, vibrant frame. There's quite a bit of tannin here, so readers will have to be patient. Saint-Pierre is always a powerhouse, but it appears to be especially brooding in 2019.
Und Neal Martin (Vinous) zum Chateau Saint Pierre 2019 Saint Julien:
The 2019 Saint-Pierre has a little more intensity and ambition than the Gloria, offering intense blackberry, boysenberry, cedar and pencil box aromas; hints of iodine come through with time. The palate is medium-bodied, dense and saline, with sappy black fruit, fine acidity and hints of black olive lending complexity on the persistent finish. A great Saint-Julien.
Der Chateau Saint Pierre 2019 Saint Julien am Gaumen der Falstaff-Verköstiger:
Dunkles Rubingranat, opaker Kern, violette Reflexe, zarte Randaufhellung. Entwickelte Nase nach Dörrpflaumen, reifen Feigen, Kakao, ein Hauch von Vanille und Nougat unterlegt. Komplex, sehr kraftvoll, wir eine Spur überreif, aromatisch eher in Richtung Vintage Port, reife Tannine, süßer Nachhall, sehr saftig, könnte sich mit der Zeit in einen großen Wein verwandeln.